Retailers often start reviewing their email marketing software when it becomes hard to automate journeys using current order, stock and customer data. A campaign recommends a product the customer bought last week, or a back-in-stock alert arrives after the item has sold out again.
Other pressures tend to follow. Unclear attribution and slipping deliverability make performance harder to judge, contact-based charges rise as the list grows, and concerns about migration delay a decision.
The best starting point is to compare how reliably each platform connects to your store, supports the journeys you depend on, measures performance, and handles the costs and responsibilities of sending email. It’s also worth asking whether you need a new platform at all. Sometimes the cause is an unreliable connector, a configuration issue or poor data governance.
Features to look for in eCommerce email marketing software
Live store data. The platform should sync orders, browsing behaviour and catalogue data, including prices, stock levels and images, from your eCommerce platform in close to real time. A long feature list offers little value if the platform can’t reliably exchange the data needed to trigger and personalise campaigns. If product data is inconsistent at source, the fix may lie in your product information management rather than in the email tool.
Check who maintains the connector: the vendor, your eCommerce platform or an implementation partner. That decides who fixes the sync when an update breaks it.
Revenue reporting you can verify. Most platforms report “email revenue”, but the figure depends on how it’s counted. A seven-day window that credits any purchase after an open will credit at least as many sales as a one-day window that requires a click, and usually more. Ask which settings apply by default and whether you can change them.
Opens are a weak basis for attribution. When Apple Mail’s Protect Mail Activity setting is on, it downloads remote content in the background by default, whether or not the recipient engages with the email, so a recorded open may not mean anyone read it. A properly designed holdout test, which excludes a random group of customers from a flow, can estimate the incremental impact that attribution can’t show.
Automated flows to test in a demo
Store integration and reporting look similar in most sales presentations. The differences show when a vendor configures real journeys using your representative catalogue data and synthetic or anonymised customer records. Agree access, processing and security arrangements before sharing any real customer data with a prospective supplier.
Six flows cover most retail email programmes:
- Welcome, triggered by sign-up, with different paths for subscribers who have and haven’t bought.
- Abandoned basket, triggered when a known customer leaves items in their basket.
- Browse abandonment, triggered by product views from an identified visitor. It relies on site tracking, so check how it respects your cookie consent settings.
- Post-purchase, covering order follow-up, reviews and care guides. A purely administrative update is a service message, but the ICO says a message that adds promotional material becomes direct marketing, so cross-sell content needs a marketing permission.
- Back-in-stock, triggered by stock changes, which shows how quickly catalogue data syncs.
- Win-back, triggered by a lapse since the last purchase and timed to suit your buying cycle.
A proposed test: the abandoned basket
Abandoned-basket emails make a useful test because they depend on customer identification, order updates, permission checks and reporting working together. Ask the vendor to run this scenario on test records (the timings are illustrative).
- Customer A consented to marketing. They leave trainers in their basket, receive a reminder an hour later, then buy the trainers before the second reminder is due the next day.
- Customer B bought running shoes last spring without consenting to marketing, but was offered a clear opt-out at checkout and didn’t use it. They abandon a basket containing running socks.
- Customer C has bought before but has since unsubscribed from marketing emails. They abandon a basket too.
The platform should recognise Customer A’s order and cancel the second reminder. Ask how quickly orders reach the platform. A platform that checks for purchases only once a day may email people about products they already own.
For Customer B, the platform should check the permission record before sending. Running socks are plausibly similar to running shoes, and an opt-out was offered, so the soft opt-in explained below may apply. Customer C must be excluded whatever their basket contains.
Finally, see how Customer A’s purchase is reported: through an open, a click or neither. That shows how the platform assigns credit, although it can’t prove the email caused the sale.
If you run a separate personalisation tool, check which system controls product recommendations in these emails. Many of the same integration questions arise when comparing eCommerce personalisation software.
Email platform or marketing automation platform?
The abandoned-basket test raises a wider question: do you want the email reminder coordinated with an SMS, a push notification or an on-site message? If you do, you’re choosing between a specialist email tool and a broader marketing automation platform.
Sending an SMS only to customers who didn’t click the first reminder needs a shared customer profile, reliable event tracking across channels and journey controls that can act on it. Ask vendors to show the journey working, not just a diagram of it.
Permissions need the same care. The ICO says opt-outs usually apply to the specific communication method, so an email unsubscribe needn’t stop texts if your wording makes that clear. A broader objection to direct marketing must be respected on every channel, so the platform should record both.
If SMS or push plays a small part in your programme, a specialist email platform may suit you better.
Deliverability: what mailbox providers now require
All of this depends on your emails reaching the inbox. The platform provides authentication tools and infrastructure, but your practices shape complaint rates.
SPF lists the servers allowed to send for your domain, DKIM adds a signature showing a message hasn’t been altered, and DMARC tells mailbox providers how to handle mail that fails those checks.
Google’s sender guidelines classify anyone sending close to 5,000 or more messages a day to personal Gmail accounts as a bulk sender, and that status doesn’t expire. Bulk senders must meet requirements including:
- SPF and DKIM authentication
- A DMARC record with at least a p=none policy, with the From: domain aligned to SPF or DKIM
- One-click unsubscribe for marketing messages, with Google advising that requests are honoured within 48 hours.
Google also recommends keeping the user-reported spam rate below 0.1% and preventing it from reaching 0.3%. Senders above 0.3% lose eligibility for mitigation if delivery problems follow.
Yahoo’s requirements are closely aligned. Since 5 May 2025, Microsoft’s Outlook.com policy has required domains sending more than 5,000 emails a day to pass SPF and DKIM and publish DMARC. Non-compliant messages go to junk and may be rejected if the problems persist.
These requirements also shape what to look for in a vendor:
- Authentication. Will the vendor help set up SPF, DKIM and DMARC on your sending domain, and add one-click unsubscribe headers by default?
- Shared or dedicated sending. A dedicated IP isolates you from other senders in a shared pool, but needs warming up and consistent volume. Either way, reputation also depends on your domain’s practices, engagement and complaints.
- Reporting. Look for complaint, bounce and inbox placement data by mailbox provider, not just open rates.
- List hygiene. Suppressing long-term unengaged contacts protects deliverability and, on contact-based pricing, reduces cost. Because opens are inflated, define engagement by clicks and purchases.
UK GDPR and PECR: the permissions behind each campaign
You also need to be sure you can lawfully send each message and use the data behind it. The ICO’s detailed guidance on electronic mail marketing, updated on 28 April 2026, covers both sets of rules.
PECR: whether you can send the message
To send unsolicited marketing emails to individuals, including sole traders and ordinary partnerships, you need consent or must meet every requirement of the products and services soft opt-in:
- You collected their details yourself, during a sale or negotiations for a sale. A quote request can count, but browsing your website doesn’t.
- You’re marketing your own similar products or services, judged by what the person would reasonably expect.
- You offered a simple opt-out when you collected their details, and you offer one in every message.
The soft opt-in can’t be used for bought-in lists, or for details collected by another organisation, even one in your own group. Act promptly on opt-outs and check your suppression list before every marketing send.
Under PECR, corporate subscribers such as limited companies can receive marketing without consent or a soft opt-in, provided you identify yourself and give a valid opt-out address. Data protection law still applies to any personal information involved, such as a named employee’s work email address.
UK GDPR: how you use the personal data
You need a lawful basis for processing as well as a PECR permission. The ICO says this is likely to be consent where you rely on consent, and legitimate interests, supported by a legitimate interests assessment, where you rely on a soft opt-in.
The same guidance notes that tracking pixels in emails fall under PECR’s separate rules on storage and access technologies. Ask vendors how their tracking works and which settings you control. Emails that draw on browsing data or profiling should also follow the consent decisions in your personalisation strategy.
In demos, ask how each platform:
- Records when, where and how each person gave consent, per channel
- Records soft opt-in eligibility separately from explicit consent
- Keeps suppression lists intact through list deletions and imports
- Hosts customer data, and what safeguards apply to any transfer outside the UK.
This is general guidance rather than legal advice, so involve your data protection lead or legal adviser before changing how you rely on consent.
How to compare eCommerce email marketing software pricing
How a platform stores profiles, permissions and suppression records can also affect what you pay. Most platforms charge in one of three ways:
- Contacts, priced by profiles stored, sometimes including unsubscribed or inactive ones.
- Sends, priced by email volume regardless of list size.
- Tiers, which bundle features with allowances and may reserve important capabilities for higher tiers.
Add-ons such as SMS credits, dedicated IPs and premium support are often charged on top of the headline price.
These models can diverge as contact numbers and sending frequency change. Ask each shortlisted vendor to quote at your current list size, at twice that size and at five times, using your real sending frequency and channel mix.
Then check the contract: which contacts count towards billing, what happens if you exceed an allowance, the notice period, and the terms for exporting your data if you leave.
Subscription costs are only part of the comparison. Rebuilding automations, transferring data, setting up sending and implementation support all belong in the total cost of ownership, so understand them before you sign.
How to migrate email marketing platforms without losing data or deliverability
The right plan depends on your volumes, current reputation and the vendor’s advice, but most migrations involve these steps:
- Export consent records and suppression lists. Unsubscribes, hard bounces and spam complaints must come with you. Sending marketing emails to people who have opted out would breach PECR, although genuine service messages, such as order updates, are treated differently.
- Export customer and engagement history, so segments and win-back timing still work.
- Review flows and templates before rebuilding them, and retire journeys that underperform.
- Authenticate the new platform on your domain before any live sending.
- Increase volume gradually, usually starting with your most engaged recipients, and keep unsubscribes in sync if both platforms run in parallel.
An evaluation checklist for your shortlist
Before your demos, decide how much weight each area deserves. A retailer with a small SMS programme might weigh channels lightly and integration heavily.
| Area | What to ask |
| Store data | Does it sync orders, browsing and catalogue data in near real time, and who maintains the connector? |
| Automated flows | Can you run the six core flows and the abandoned-basket test on our test records? |
| Revenue reporting | Which attribution settings apply by default, and can we run holdout tests? |
| Channels | Are SMS, push and on-site messages extra, and can journeys act on activity across all of them? |
| Deliverability | Shared or dedicated sending, and what help is there with authentication and one-click unsubscribe? |
| Compliance | How are consent, soft opt-in status, tracking and suppression lists handled, and where is our data hosted? |
| Pricing | What would we pay at two and five times our current list size, and what costs extra? |
| Support and switching | Who supports the integration, what migration and warm-up help is included, and how do we export our data? |
Taking your shortlist further at the eCommerce Forum
A platform that passes every feature test can still be the wrong choice if its integration maintenance, implementation support or future costs don’t suit your business. The final decision should reflect the requirements that matter most to your operation, not the longest feature list.
Supplier conversations can show where further demonstrations or technical checks are needed before you commit. The eCommerce Forum takes place on 4 February 2027 at Hilton London Canary Wharf, where qualifying eCommerce professionals are hosted for a programme of pre-arranged 20-minute one-to-one meetings and seminars.
You indicate the suppliers and solution areas you’d like to explore, and the event team builds your meeting itinerary around those preferences. Attendance is by invitation and subject to confirmation, and buyers commit to the full day and their arranged itinerary.
Apply to attend the eCommerce Forum as a buyer
Frequently asked questions
Does the soft opt-in cover someone who asked for a quote but didn’t buy?
It can. The ICO treats a quote request or asking for more details as negotiations for a sale, provided you collected the details yourself and offered an opt-out at the time.
Which records should we export before cancelling our old platform?
At a minimum, export consent records with their source and date, soft opt-in eligibility, suppression lists, order and engagement history, and your templates.
Will our suppression list transfer automatically when we switch?
Don’t assume it will. Migration tools differ, so confirm how suppression records are exported and imported, load them before the first send, and check that later imports or sign-up syncs can’t re-add suppressed addresses.
Image credit: https://unsplash.com/photos/envelope-shaped-bokeh-lights-vSlCNmZdjHQ







